Confession: As I was making these, I couldn’t shake this weird feeling that I was doing something terrible. I mean, you get Thin Mints once a year, maybe twice if you’re lucky, and there I was, smashing up half a box of them, turning them into a different cookie entirely. I felt like a monster.
But you know what? If making these makes me a monster, I’ll take being a monster. These might be the most amazing cookies I’ve ever made.